8 Police officers had died in Greensboro or the surrounding area last year and their families needed help. 35 Dollars would go a long way towards helping their families, or so I was told, and this would be a silver level donation. I'm sure you know this conversation without me telling you the rest. I was sympathetic, but apologetic, that we had in fact given to quite a lot of charities lately and could't help them. Of course the gentleman understood, and agreed that 35 dollars was quite a lot and anything at all would help them. As he pressed valiantly ahead in the same breath, not giving pause in the conversation to which I could express my regrets and wrap the whole thing up, he added a new wrinkle to the conversation I thought I knew. Instead of mentioning how easy it would be to send me an envelope that I could stuff whatever money I could spare, he offered to run the same 15 dollars I had given to them last time, on the same card I had used to pay with, quoting over the phone the last 4 digits of it.
The subtext to this is: I had given to this charity before, the situation to which i gave the money in the first place had worsened as 8 officers as opposed to 5 had died. I was now trying to take the position that I wasn't going to be supporting them. "What has changed?" is what I heard as he read those 4 numbers of my credit card.
Nothing has changed, except the way they do business. Charity telemarketers are in the business of selling you something insubstantial, something you can't see and don't know you're paying for when you agree to give them money: guilt. Men I know nothing about, have my credit information, number and all, on record and in hand. I am truly in awe in of the way charities of this variety have evolved. I'm pretty sure mr. country accent talking to me on the other end of the phone had nothing but the best of intentions in what he was doing. I'm also sure his rhetoric is almost identical to the person sitting 2 feet away on the phone next to him. Having come from some afternoon long training course along with a couple hours of a supervisor sitting next to him listening to him add his own folksy icing to the exact same cake he just told him how to make.
Don't get me wrong. I support different charities throughout the year, I understand how they are needed and what good they can do. However, the process is disgusting at some of these local level phone based organizations. The local police, fire and hospitals would , you think, be able to smell an intrusive and unfair system with all the morals of a game of three-card-monte, out. You know what team the guy on the other end of the phone is playing for and you've seen the rules: keep the person on the line as long as possible, appeal to their civic pride, press guilt onto them, pull the heartstrings, and leave no windows for rebuttal or questions by always ending with one of your own. "Can I go ahead and count on your support", means: "Don't ask me anything." Questions like: "What percentage of the money I'm pledging actually gets to the people who need the money?" are unwanted and only slow things down.
I don't like this ambush mentality, and even though I've spent this time ranting about it, I will still probably give to telemarketer-faced charities like Make-a-wish. I just don't like the practices, and I especially don't like having 5 minutes of my day taken to make me feel like a complete shit for not saving the world with my 15 dollar donations. Maybe I should start a non-profit charity to look into the ethics of these other charities. Or at least get caller ID.
Thanks for coming